Blog

I'm a Good Manager, but Am I Also a Good Leader?

Maxwell Leadership Europe · · 6 min read

Leaders in conversation at a Maxwell Leadership event

A good manager keeps the work in order: processes, tasks, deadlines and systems that run smoothly. A good leader has something a position can never give: people who follow by choice. You can have both, but they are not the same thing. Leadership is earned in three ways: you help people grow, you care about them and you keep your word. The reflection checklist below will help you see where you stand.

Perhaps this sounds familiar. The team delivers, deadlines are met and the end-of-quarter report looks good. And yet your best team member resigns, and in the exit conversation simply says they received a better offer.

Most of the time, it isn't only about the offer. The processes worked, but the leadership was missing. The work got done, but people quietly stopped following you.

Management and leadership: two different things

Management is about things: processes, tasks, systems, deadlines. Leadership is about people: influence, trust, growth. You need both, but one cannot replace the other.

John C. Maxwell puts it simply: “Leadership is influence. Nothing more, nothing less.” In his model of the five levels of leadership, position is only the first level, the one where people follow you because they have to. Your position gives you the right to hand out tasks. The right to be followed is something you earn separately.

People buy into the leader first and only then into the vision. If you ask for commitment before you have earned it, you are doing things in the wrong order. What you get is compliance, and compliance lasts only until a better offer comes along.

Research shows it too: Gallup finds that the person who directly leads a team accounts for 70% of the variance in engagement between teams. Think about what that means: the same company, the same rules, the same job title on the door, and yet completely different teams. The difference is not the title, but the way the person in front of the team wins people over.

First, the management foundation

Before you look at leadership, check the foundation. Unclear goals and priorities that change from one day to the next drain more energy than the work itself. A good manager takes care of these things:

  • clear expectations and honest feedback;
  • priorities protected from day-to-day noise;
  • tasks delegated together with the authority to decide;
  • consistency, so people know what to expect;
  • decisions explained: you share the reason, not just the outcome.

All of these are necessary. But they make you a good manager, not a leader. The checklist below helps you reflect only on the second part: whether people follow you.

Reflection checklist: do people follow you or just obey you?

Mentally tick only what is true today, not what you intend to do. Only you will see the answers, so be honest.

  • I know what each person on my team wants for their career, not just what tasks they have.
  • In one-to-one conversations, we talk about the person first and only then about the work.
  • This month I asked someone “What can I take off your plate?” and actually did what they asked.
  • I can name at least one person who grew this year partly because I invested in them.
  • I don't lead everyone the same way: I know who wants recognition in front of the team and who prefers a kind word in private.
  • I write down what I promise in meetings and check every week that I have kept my word.
  • People come to me with a problem before it becomes a crisis.
  • When I propose something new, people get involved because they believe in me, not just because of my position.
  • If I lost my position tomorrow, most of my team would still come to me for advice.

What your ticks mean

  • 0 to 3 ticks: you are probably relying more on your position than on influence. People do what you ask, but no more. The good news: nothing on the list requires a budget, only consistency.
  • 4 to 6 ticks: you have started to win people over, but not everyone and not always. The statements you didn't tick show you the next step.
  • 7 or more: you have many of the habits of leaders whom people follow by choice. Check this by asking them. Then you can help others around you lead the same way.

These thresholds are only a guide, chosen by us to help you reflect, not a validated score. Don't use the checklist to assess or compare people. The most reliable answer comes from your team: ask them.

The three questions behind the checklist

The statements were not chosen at random. Chris Goede and Perry Holley of Maxwell Leadership say that every person on your team silently asks three questions about you. The answers decide whether they follow you willingly.

Can you help me? Whether it is a new project or a new leader, the first thing people want to know is how it affects them. When it is clear that you are investing in someone's growth, you give them a reason to invest back.

Do you care about me? Nobody gives their all for someone who treats them as just a unit of production. The Golden Rule says to treat others as you would like to be treated. The Platinum Rule of leadership goes further: you lead people the way they need to be led. If you lead everyone your own way, you only reach the people who are like you.

Can I trust you? Trust always grows the same way: you make a promise and you keep it. Most of the time, it breaks through carelessness: a forgotten promise, a meeting where you were only half listening, an answer you promised that never came. Every small slip costs more than it seems.

How do you think your people would answer each of these three questions?

Your next step: start on Monday

Choose one statement you didn't tick and turn it into a habit. Here are a few starting points, none of which need a budget or anyone's approval:

  • For “Can you help me?”: ask someone “What can I take off your plate?” and do what they ask. Help becomes credible the first time you act on it.
  • For “Do you care about me?”: in your next one-to-one, talk about the person first: what they want, what frustrates them, what is happening at home. This is how you learn how they need to be led.
  • For “Can I trust you?”: write down everything you promise in meetings and close every promise by Friday.

A gesture made once doesn't change much. The same gesture repeated week after week changes the way people see you. Consistency is what makes influence credible.

Consistency is what makes influence credible.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a manager and a leader?

Management is about processes, tasks and systems: the work is organised, priorities are clear and deadlines are met. Leadership is about people and influence: people follow you because they believe in you, not because they have a boss. Your position gives you the right to hand out tasks, but the right to be followed is something you earn separately.

Can you be a good manager without being a good leader?

Yes, and it happens often. You can have flawless processes and a team that does only the bare minimum. The difference shows when a better offer or a difficult period comes along: people stay and commit for a leader, not for a position.

What mistakes stop people who lead teams from becoming leaders?

Three come up most often: controlling every detail, avoiding difficult conversations and leading everyone the same way. Excessive control takes away people's sense that the work is theirs. Avoiding hard conversations lowers standards, and using the same style for everyone keeps you distant from those who are not like you.

How do you earn the trust of a new team?

You don't start with changes. In the first month, you get to know the people, the work and the way things are done. In the second, you start contributing and building relationships, and only in the third do you take full ownership of the goals. Meanwhile, you write down what you promise and keep your word, because that is the only way trust grows.

This article was first published in Romanian on the blog of Maxwell Leadership Romania. Read the original ↗

Grow as a leader with John C. Maxwell's method

Maxwell Leadership Europe brings John C. Maxwell's leadership programs, certification and books to your country. Tell us what you are looking for and we will answer you personally.

Talk to us