Blog

How to Give an Employee Feedback Without Demotivating Them

Maxwell Leadership Europe · · 6 min read

Two colleagues talking during a Maxwell Leadership event

An employee doesn't lose motivation because of feedback. They lose motivation because of the feeling they are left with after the conversation. To give feedback without demotivating someone, start from their context, tell them specifically what they did well, ask them to improve just one thing and show them what they gain from the change, not only what the company gains. And more important than any technique: let them see your good intentions.

You may already know the sandwich method: some praise, a criticism, then more praise. You applied it carefully. And yet the person walked out of your office with slumped shoulders, and the next day they worked half-heartedly. What happened?

Leadership is influence. And in a feedback conversation, your influence is decided in just a few minutes, in the way the person leaves the room.

Most of the time, the problem is neither the other person nor you. The problem lies in a few things we believe about feedback. Let's take them one by one.

Myth 1: “The sandwich method makes criticism easy to accept”

The myth: If you place your observation between two compliments, the person will accept it without getting upset.

The truth: People only remember what comes after the “but”. A single “but” erases everything kind you said before it.

Think of a sentence you may have said yourself: “Your presentation was very clear, but you talked for too long.” What does the person remember? Only the second half. The praise at the start was just the wrapping for the criticism. And the next time you praise them, they are already bracing for the blow.

Maxwell Leadership mentors suggest a small change with a big effect: instead of “but”, say “that's exactly why”, “so” or “for that reason”. “Your presentation was very clear. That's exactly why, if you make it shorter, the client will remember it even better.” The praise stays standing, and the improvement becomes the next step, not a punishment.

There is one condition: the benefit has to be real for that person. If you use kind words only to push them where you want them to go, it is no longer feedback. It is manipulation. And people can feel it.

Myth 2: “If I tell them everything that needs fixing, they'll grow faster”

The myth: A complete list of mistakes helps them fix everything at once.

The truth: A long list overwhelms. People grow one step at a time, a step they can take before the next conversation.

When you see five things to correct, it is tempting to mention all of them. You're just being honest, right? Except the person leaves feeling that nothing went well. Choose one thing, two at most, that they can sort out before next time.

More feedback doesn't mean better feedback. Gallup found that only 26% of employees strongly agree that the feedback they receive helps them do better work. What matters is what stays with the person after you have spoken.

Feedback that builds people up has three simple steps:

  • What they did well. Be specific, not just “it was fine”. Say exactly what you liked and why.
  • What they can improve. Just one thing, described as a fact: what they did and what to do next time. Avoid “always” and “never”, which are rarely true.
  • Why. What they gain from the change, not only what the company or the team gains.

Perry Holley, a coach on John C. Maxwell's team, advises leaders to describe the action as precisely as possible and not to judge the person. “Your report was two days late” is something that can be fixed. “You're unreliable” only hurts.

Myth 3: “If they get defensive, they don't want to change”

The myth: Someone who justifies themselves isn't open to feedback, so there's no point in pushing.

The truth: Someone who gets defensive usually feels they have to prove their worth to you.

Perry Holley makes a simple observation: when people are busy proving their value, they are no longer busy growing. Anyone who is afraid of being judged will show you only their successes and hide their mistakes. Your job as a leader is to help them move from “I need to look good” to “I want to grow”.

That starts with questions, not verdicts. After a project or a client meeting, ask them:

  • What was the best moment?
  • What could have gone better? (not “what went wrong”)
  • What did you learn about yourself from this situation?
  • What will you do differently next time?

Very often, the person sees for themselves exactly what you wanted to tell them. And if something has suddenly changed in the way they work, first ask yourself what is happening in their life. Maxwell Leadership mentors say that before you correct a behaviour, you need to understand where it comes from.

Myth 4: “If I care about them, I'd better say nothing”

The myth: Caring for people means being kind to them and not correcting them.

The truth: Silence doesn't protect them. It lets them repeat the same mistake until it becomes a big problem.

John C. Maxwell notes that many leaders misunderstand what it means to care for people, as if it meant never correcting them. That is how a bad day becomes a bad week, and then a bad month. Perry Holley says feedback is a gift you give someone, so they know how they are doing. If you feel uncomfortable, accept it and speak up anyway. People will respect you for it.

But a gift has to be given with the right heart. Perry Holley points out that everyone around you is asking three questions about you: Can you help me? Do you care about me? Can I trust you? If your intentions pass these three questions, you are ready to speak openly.

John C. Maxwell says that two things help you in a difficult conversation: honesty and sincerity. Don't sweeten reality until it is no longer true, and do it for the other person's good, with the intention of helping them.

Start the conversation from gratitude for what the person brings, not from accusation. And keep it one to one. As Sorin Popa, President of Maxwell Leadership Romania, puts it: correct in private, praise in public.

John C. Maxwell's father used to say that encouragement is oxygen to the soul. Good feedback doesn't leave people gasping for air. It gives them the air they need to keep going.

Before your next feedback conversation

Next time, before you call someone in for a conversation, stop for a minute and ask yourself:

  • Do I know what is going on in their life right now?
  • What is the one thing I want them to change?
  • What do they gain from this change?
  • If they could read my mind right now, would they see that I want to help them?

Frequently asked questions

What is feedback?

Feedback is the information you give someone about how they are doing: what is going well and what they can do better. On John C. Maxwell's team it is called a gift, because it helps people grow. Good feedback describes specific facts and ends with a clear next step.

What should you do if an employee gets defensive when receiving feedback?

Don't keep pressing your arguments. People usually get defensive because they feel they need to prove their worth. Ask them questions: what went well, what could have gone better, what they will do differently next time. Let them reach the conclusion themselves.

Should negative feedback be given in public or in private?

In private. Praise in public, correct one to one. A correction made in front of the team humiliates the person and makes them defensive, even if you are right.

When is the right time to give an employee feedback?

As soon as possible after you notice the problem, not when “the right moment” comes along. If you put it off, a bad day turns into a bad week or a bad month. The conversation is easier when the facts are fresh and can still be changed.

This article was first published in Romanian on the blog of Maxwell Leadership Romania. Read the original ↗

Grow as a leader with John C. Maxwell's method

Maxwell Leadership Europe brings John C. Maxwell's leadership programs, certification and books to your country. Tell us what you are looking for and we will answer you personally.

Talk to us